Butler blue

Butler University

Once the underdog.

Now, a household name.


Uncovering the data that

unleashed the Butler brand.

The Challenge

The Opportunity

Fame can be fleeting. You don’t have to make back-to-back NCAA tournament championship appearances, as Butler University did in 2010 and 2011, to know that. But even a brief moment (or two) in the sun provides a rare opportunity to think long-term. Soon after the wins, Butler launched the first of multiple research studies to not only measure and track brand perception but also to use that data to evolve brand strategy and creative—over the course of a decade. It's quite a story.*

*In fact, a book about it was recently released called The Cinderella Strategy: The Game Plan Behind Butler University’s Rise to Prominence. Let us know if you’d like a copy; we’re confident we can get our hands on one (or two).

Narrative slide

The Solution

In 2014, we helped Butler launch its brand strategy — “The Right Outcomes. The Right Way.” At that same time, we also established a proprietary brand equity index and aligned it to Butler’s 2020 strategic plan, enabling Marketing to regularly and reliably measure the strategy’s success and if they were mapping to the brand. Replication studies conducted in 2016 and 2018 showed they were.

students in lecture students in lecture

Butler’s consistent strategic and creative evolutions, informed by long-term research data, has led to significant improvements to brand equity, as well as to new initiatives.”

Matt McFadden; SimpsonScarborough VP, Strategy


The Right Outcomes.
The Right Way.

Butler University readies its students for successful careers and meaningful lives by combining an intimate academic environment with real-world experiences to create compassionate, adaptive thinkers.


A good life is more than a good job. And a college degree is more than what you learn in the classroom. At Butler, the meaningful interactions and experiences you share with a close-knit community ensure that you’re ready. Small classes, opportunities to engage directly with faculty, and real-world experience—through internships, research with faculty mentors, performances, and community engagement—gives students the knowledge and skills required to get to work. The Butler Way drives us to always seek better—better outcomes, a better community, and a better world.

Butler Campus Sign


Staying true to strategy over time to grow brand equity.

Butler has integrated the brand promise, messaging, and visuals into every aspect of its marketing, from the university website to recruitment communications, social media campaigns, and even an institutional mascot strategy.

Just four years after the brand launch, awareness of Butler as an excellent institution had significantly increased among prospective students

14% increase
Butler Campus

By 2018, Butler saw increases among alumni associating Butler with strengths in areas that were emphasized in the brand strategy, including experiential learning, graduate programs, service, and—most significantly—outcomes.

Desktop render
Magazine and Environmental
Blue Unleashed
Scope of work

Scope of Work

Scope 0

Brand perception research with prospective students, parents, and alumni and the creation of a custom brand equity index to track key measures of impact.

Scope 1

A new brand strategy for the University; messaging architecture for the campus, including enrollment and advancement; and custom brand platforms and messaging strategies for each of Butler's six schools 
and colleges.

Scope 2

Multiple brand integrations including a new suite of enrollment materials, a branded ad campaign targeting influencers in Indianapolis, a yield campaign and, possibly, the first-ever live mascot brand strategy.

The Results

Now in its 7th year, our partnership has produced phenomenal results, including meeting the 2020 strategic plan’s brand equity goal and standing up a 2021 March Madness media campaign that garnered 52 million ad impressions for the university.

Butler Brand Wins

  • 31% application increase.
  • 21% overall deposit increase.
  • Largest incoming freshman class in Butler history (2016).
  • Met 2020 strategic plan goal of 15%
    overall brand equity increase.
  • 15,800 media mentions associated with the 2021 branded March Madness campaign.
Students on campus Students on campus

SimpsonScarborough changed the trajectory for Butler.”

—Stephanie Judge Cripe,
 Associate Vice President Marketing 
and Communications

Essential insights. Delivered monthly.